The moves to shore up SIP and SIMPLE come amid increasing pressure to
produce full-featured interoperability standards. This is especially true
in the instant messaging arena, as enterprises are eager to exert control on
employees' IM use, but risk cutting them off from the outside world without
widely-supported protocols for server-to-server interoperability.
In late summer, seven financial services giants -- Credit Suisse First
Boston, Deutsche Bank, J.P. Morgan Chase
, Lehman Brothers, Merrill Lynch, Morgan Stanley and UBS Warburg -- began efforts to leverage their collective clout to encourage
standards for instant messaging in the banking industry, particularly with
regard to interoperability.
Several vendors, meanwhile, have pulled back from SIMPLE at least in part
because of its lack of more robust features. Microsoft, expected to include
SIP support in its Greenwich server, is believed to have pushed back the
ship date for the product -- which handles voice over IP, application
sharing, and instant messaging -- due in part to concerns about the
robustness of SIMPLE security and other features.
AOL Time Warner's IM leader America Online said it had
initially explored ways to integrate SIP into its long-expected enterprise
IM offering. But when that product debuted last week, it lacked SIMPLE
compatibility -- due to what the company said was a lack of necessary
features in the protocol, and the excessive cost of an implementation.
E-mail and messaging giant Gordano said last week that it had no
immediate plans to support SIP interoperability in its new IM product --
citing a lack of demand from its clients, and shortcomings in the current
SIMPLE specifications. Even IBM, which became one of
SIMPLE's largest users early last month, when it launched a SIP-compliant
version of its Lotus SameTime enterprise IM product, has conceded that
SIMPLE functions remain primitive compared to its proprietary messaging
protocol.
To its credit, SIP already has big-name support in the world of telephony
and wireless messaging. The Third Generation Partnership Project, Europe's
alliance of mobile telecommunications standards bodies, is signaling its
support for SIP in the next version of its wireless network specifications.
And a host of vendors -- including Nortel, Mitel, Siemens
, Sun Microsystems, Ericsson , and Alcatel-- are already marketing
telephony, wireless and networking products that incorporate SIP.
But its application remains controversial in instant messaging -- a fact
that SIMPLE's authors are hoping to soon change.
"We've got the core mechanics in place," Sparks said. "It's in use.
What the group is picking up on now is just fine-tuning -- honing-in on this
session-messaging concept and looking at advanced management features."
Christopher Saunders is managing editor of Instant Messaging Planet.